L. A. Paul Truth Conditions of Tensed Sentence Types
نویسنده
چکیده
Quentin Smith has argued that the new tenseless theory of time is faced with insurmountable problems and should be abandoned in favour of the tensed theory of time. Smith’s main argument attacks the fundamental premise of the tenseless theory: that tenseless truth conditions for tokens of tensed sentences adequately capture the meaning of tensed sentences. His position is that tenseless truth conditions cannot explain the logical relations between tensed sentences, thus the tensed theory must be accepted. Against Smith, this paper adopts an alternative approach to the explanation of the entailment relations between sentences which contain indexicals. The approach drops the reliance upon tokens and instead relies on the evaluation of sentence types with respect to a context rather than upon actual or possible utterances of tokens of the types. This (new) version of the tenseless theory of time can adequately explain the relevant entailment relations between tensed sentences.
منابع مشابه
Tokens, Dates And Tenseless Truth Conditions
There are two extant versions of the new tenseless theory of time: the date version and the token-reflexive version. I ask whether they are equivalent, and if not, which of them is to be preferred. I argue that they are not equivalent, that the date version is unsatisfactory, and that the token-reflexive version is correct. I defend the tokenreflexive version against a string of objections from...
متن کاملAmerican English usage frequencies for noun phrase and tensed sentence complement-taking verbs.
The present research documents the American English usage frequencies for 136 verbs that occur with noun phrase and tensed sentence complements (e.g., accepted, noun phrase complement: The student knew the answer yesterday, tensed sentence complement: The student knew the answer was correct). This class of verbs has been the focus of numerous empirical studies investigating how syntactic ambigu...
متن کاملBeyond Truth Conditions: The Semantics of most
The language faculty generates expressions that relate sounds and meanings, but it is not immediately obvious exactly what kind of formal object “meanings” are. A common assumption is that sentence meanings are truth conditions: unstructured functions from worlds to truth values.1 By looking at the relationship between language understanding and verification procedures, this paper explores the ...
متن کاملSmith On Times And Tokens
In this essay I respond to Quentin Smith’s charge that ‘the date-analysis version of the tenseless theory of time cannot give adequate accounts of the truth conditions of the statements made by tensed sentence-tokens’ (Smith 1999, 236). His argument is based on an analysis of certain counterfactual situations that is at odds with the date-analysis account of language and hence succeeds only in ...
متن کامل